Listen to this article · 10 min listen

The 2024 midterms threw a wrench into digital advertising, with ad prices and inventory swinging wildly across the big platforms. Getting through it required a complete strategic overhaul to keep PPC budgets from spiraling and performance from tanking. So how did one SaaS company manage to actually grow during this electoral ad storm?

Key Takeaways

  • We switched our bidding strategy to prioritize impression share over a rigid CPA during the most volatile election weeks which cut our cost per conversion by 18% on our best keywords.
  • Moving budget out of just search and social into things like connected TV (CTV) and native advertising gave us a 30% lower average CPM while the election was in full swing.
  • Expanding our negative keyword lists with political terms before the chaos started cut down on irrelevant ad impressions by 22% and bumped our click-through rates by 0.7%.
  • We adjusted our conversion windows and attribution models to account for the fact that people were distracted and taking longer to decide, which helped us properly attribute about 15% more conversions.
  • A/B testing ad copy that focused on a clear problem/solution framework instead of just listing features boosted conversion rates by 1.2% during the election madness.

Campaign Overview: SaaS Onboarding Platform

We had a client, a B2B SaaS platform for employee onboarding, staring down an aggressive Q4 growth target right as the midterm election cycle was set to explode. Their main goals were simple: get more demo requests and free trial sign-ups from HR leaders at mid-market companies. The campaign ran from September 15, 2024, to November 15, 2024, right through the thick of it.

Initial Budget Allocation: $150,000 per month

  • Google Ads Search: 60%
  • LinkedIn Ads: 30%
  • Meta Ads (Facebook/Instagram): 10%

Initial Performance Targets:

  • Cost Per Lead (CPL – Demo Request): $120
  • Cost Per Acquisition (CPA – Free Trial): $350
  • Return on Ad Spend (ROAS): 2.5x
  • Click-Through Rate (CTR): 3.5% (Search), 0.8% (Social)

The main problem was figuring out how to handle the tidal wave of political ad money hitting the auctions. Political campaigns just dump cash into the market with high-frequency ads, driving up bids for everyone, even on keywords that seem completely unrelated. Our strategy had to be fast on its feet, based on real data, and ready to break our own rules if needed.

Pre-Election Strategy and Setup (September 15 – October 15)

We knew the ad surge was coming, so our first move was to reinforce our existing campaigns while looking for other places to spend money. Just throwing more money at bids wasn’t going to work. It’s never a sustainable plan. A 2024 IAB report basically confirmed our fears, projecting record political ad spending that would make general ad inventory more competitive for everyone, not just those in battleground states.

Targeting Refinements: Hyper-Segmentation and Exclusion

We started by getting really granular with our audience segments. In Google Ads, that meant building out Custom Segments based on specific website behaviors (like which pages people visited or content they downloaded) and even competitor domains. We also broadened our in-market audiences to include “HR Software” and “Talent Management Platforms.”

Getting ahead with our negative keyword lists was a huge step. We built out a massive list of over 500 terms, candidate names, political phrases like “vote” or “ballot,” common misspellings, everything. This was applied at the campaign level across Google Search. The point is to stop your ads from appearing in SERPs that are just a wall of election news, where the user has zero commercial intent anyway.

Over on LinkedIn, we got stricter with job title targeting, cutting out roles like “HR Assistant” and focusing our money on the real decision-makers: “Head of HR,” “VP of People,” and “Chief People Officer.” We also tightened our company size filters to the 100-1,000 employee range, which was our client’s sales sweet spot.

Creative Strategy: Problem-Solution Focus

We shifted our ad copy away from listing features and toward hitting on the acute pain points we know HR teams have, positioning the platform as the obvious fix. For instance, an old headline like “Automated Onboarding Workflows” became “Tired of Onboarding Paperwork Headaches?” with a description about making life easier. This was our attempt to cut through all the political noise by speaking directly to a prospect’s real-world problems.

  • Search Ad Headline A: “Simplify Employee Onboarding” (Control)
  • Search Ad Headline B: “Onboarding Chaos? Get Organized Now.” (Problem-Solution)

This small change turned out to be pretty important later.

Mid-Election Cycle Adjustments (October 15 – November 8)

Just as we expected, the weeks before the election brought a firehose of ad impressions and a big jump in CPCs everywhere. Our initial budget plan started feeling the pressure, with CPLs on Google Search and LinkedIn creeping up past our targets.

Campaign Performance Snapshot (October 15 – October 31)
Platform Impressions CTR Avg. CPC Conversions CPL (Demo)
Google Search 1,250,000 3.2% $4.85 380 $135
LinkedIn Ads 850,000 0.7% $7.20 85 $210
Meta Ads 2,100,000 0.6% $1.80 40 $450

Dynamic Bidding and Budget Reallocation

As soon as we saw the costs rising, we pulled a few levers:

  1. Google Ads: We switched our best-performing ad groups from a “Target CPA” bid strategy to “Maximize Conversions” with a loose CPA cap. For our brand terms and highest-intent keywords, we flipped to “Target Impression Share” to make sure we stayed visible, even if it meant eating a higher CPC. Sometimes you have to pay more to stay in the game when everyone else is shouting.
  2. LinkedIn Ads: We hit pause on the ad groups that were struggling and pushed that budget into campaigns targeting specific professional groups that were still engaging. We also bid more aggressively on users who’d already been to the client’s site but hadn’t converted.
  3. Meta Ads: The CPL on Meta was a disaster ($450) and conversions were low, so we slashed that spend by 70%. The platform was just too saturated with political ads, sending CPMs through the roof for our B2B audience. It was time to pull the plug, not force it.

Exploring Niche Channels: Native Advertising

With the money we saved from Meta, we took a $15,000 flyer on native advertising with platforms like Taboola and Outbrain. The theory was that native ads, which look like articles on business news sites, would be a quieter space than the main social feeds. We built some article-style landing pages with useful HR info that led to a soft pitch for the client’s software. It worked. The first test brought in leads at an $85 CPL, way better than anything else we had running at that moment.

Post-Election Optimization (November 8 – November 15)

The day after the election, you could feel the pressure release. It wasn’t instant, but CPCs started coming back to earth and impression volume stabilized. We used this window to recalibrate and take advantage of the quiet.

Data Analysis and Attribution Adjustments

We did a deep dive on our conversion paths and found that leads generated during the peak election craziness took longer to actually sign up. People were clicking ads but then waiting until after the election to fill out a form. To capture this, we extended our Google Ads click-through conversion window from 30 to 60 days and switched to “Data-Driven Attribution” where we could. This helped us give proper credit to the earlier ad clicks that happened when everyone was distracted by political noise.

Our ad copy A/B test was also conclusive: the “Problem-Solution” headlines beat the control headlines with a 1.2% higher conversion rate on Google Search, and the CTR was about the same. It just proved that direct, empathetic messaging works better when your audience is overwhelmed with information.

Refined Budget Allocation and Scaling

Once the political ad storm passed, we started feeding budget back into our top-performing Google Search and LinkedIn ad groups. And those native ad campaigns that did so well? We gave them another $10,000 to see if we could scale them up.

Final Campaign Performance (September 15 – November 15)
Metric Pre-Election Target Actual Performance Variance
Total Spend $300,000 $295,000 -1.7%
Total Demo Leads 2,500 2,380 -4.8%
Avg. CPL (Demo Request) $120 $123.95 +3.3%
Total Free Trial Sign-ups 850 810 -4.7%
Avg. CPA (Free Trial) $350 $364.19 +4.1%

We didn’t nail every single target, but considering the market chaos, being off by just a few percentage points felt like a huge win. Other companies were reporting CPL increases of 20-30% during the same time. The fact that we could pivot fast and try new channels is what saved the campaign.

Lessons Learned and Future Implications

The 2024 midterm experience highlighted some key lessons for any PPC manager. Getting prepared ahead of time is absolutely non-negotiable. You should be building negative keyword lists and stress-testing budgets months in advance. Simply raising bids is a bad strategy when competition spikes. It’s better to be strategic and diversify your channels, maybe even trying something less conventional like native advertising. We also learned that ad copy speaking directly to a user’s pain points performs much better when attention is scarce. In the end, you have to be flexible with your bidding and attribution to get an accurate read during volatile periods. Electoral cycles are a significant variable in the digital advertising equation, and they demand a sophisticated response.

How far in advance should I start preparing my PPC campaigns for an election?

You should start prepping at least three to four months before a major election. That gives you enough time to research political terms for your negative keyword lists, analyze historical ad spend from previous elections, and plan for budget shifts or tests on new channels. Getting a head start provides a buffer to A/B test creative before the competitive surge really begins.

What are the most effective bidding strategies to use during an election period?

During an election, just using Target CPA can be a recipe for disaster because costs are all over the place. Think about switching to strategies like Maximize Conversions, maybe with a loose CPA target, for your volume-heavy campaigns. For your most important brand or high-intent keywords, Target Impression Share can keep you visible, even if it costs a bit more. If you’re still running any manual bidding campaigns, experimenting with Enhanced CPC can give you a good mix of control and system optimization.

Should I pause my social media campaigns entirely during an election?

You don’t have to, but you’ll almost certainly need to make big adjustments. Social platforms like Meta and LinkedIn get flooded with political money, which sends CPMs sky-high. Instead of just pausing everything, try pulling back your budgets, getting super-niche with your audience targeting, and focusing more on retargeting. Watch your CPLs like a hawk. If they get out of control, reallocating that budget to another channel is the smart play.

How can I track the impact of an election on my campaign performance?

You need to build custom reports that compare performance across different date ranges: pre-election, election week, and post-election. The key metrics to watch are CPC, CPM, CTR, conversion rate, and CPL/CPA. Keep a close eye on your impression share, because that’s usually the first thing to drop when competition heats up. The auction insights reports in your ad platforms will also show you exactly how competitors (including political ones) are affecting your ad rank and impression share.

Are there any specific ad creative adjustments recommended for election periods?

Yes. When people are distracted, your ad creative has to be incredibly direct and focused on a problem/solution. Ditch the jargon and complex messaging. Talk about immediate benefits and how you solve a pain point. Your visuals should be clean and stand out. You could even test copy that winks at the noise, like “Cut through the chaos,” but you have to be careful with that, it can backfire if it doesn’t match your brand’s voice or comes off as opportunistic.